On This Page
A 4-Step System to Find the Best Card for You
Stop asking “what is the best credit card” and start asking “what is the best credit card for me?” It’s a critical shift. The card that’s perfect for a frequent flyer is useless for someone who spends most of their money on groceries. For beginners, the goal is to ignore the marketing and use a simple, data-driven process. This guide provides that exact 4-step system. This is the same framework I’ve used for a decade to analyze credit cards and optimize my own wallet.
| Card Type | Key Specs or Features | Pros | Cons | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Travel Points Cards | Earns points like Chase Ultimate Rewards® or Amex Membership Rewards® that can be transferred to airline and hotel partners. | Extremely high potential value (2-5+ cents per point), large sign-up bonuses, premium travel perks. | Complex to use well, value isn’t fixed, often have annual fees, risk of point devaluation. | People with specific travel goals, optimizers, and those who spend heavily on dining and travel. |
| Simple Cash Back Cards | Earns a fixed percentage of your spending (e.g., 1.5% to 5%) back as a statement credit or direct deposit. | Incredibly simple, predictable value, rewards can be used for anything, many no-annual-fee options. | Lower maximum value, smaller sign-up bonuses, fewer premium perks like lounge access. | Beginners, people who value simplicity, or anyone whose budget is focused on everyday spending, not travel. |
Think of it like this: travel points are a foreign currency. With some research, you can get an amazing exchange rate for a business class flight. Cash back is just US dollars, simple and predictable. I once redeemed 120,000 points for a round-the-world flight that would have cost over $8,000, a value of nearly 7 cents per point. That’s an outcome cash back can never achieve. However, I’ve also seen people redeem those same points for a $1,200 gift card because they found the travel system too complicated.
Category Winners for Beginners
Best Overall
For most beginners who are ready to step up, the Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card is the clear winner. It’s one of the most recommended credit cards for good credit because its points are flexible, valuable, and easy to understand. It’s the perfect entry point into the world of travel rewards without being overwhelming. I recommend this card to over 80% of friends and family who ask for advice. The annual fee means you need to spend enough on travel and dining to make it worthwhile.
Related internal guide about the Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card
Best Budget
A no-annual-fee, flat-rate cash back card is the most practical starting point. The Citi® Double Cash Card, which gives 2% back on everything, is a workhorse. You give up travel perks, but you get solid, predictable value on every purchase. A $1,500 monthly spend on this card nets a simple $360 per year, no questions asked.
Best Premium
If you’re a frequent traveler and can manage a spreadsheet, The Platinum Card® from American Express is in a league of its own. You have to be organized to use the mountain of credits it offers. The card includes credits for airlines, Uber, hotels, digital entertainment, and more, which can exceed the annual fee. It’s a tool for serious optimizers.
Realistic Math Examples
Highest Value Scenario (Travel Points)
- Reference cost: $4,000 (Business Class Flight)
- Inputs or effort: 80,000 points + $120 in taxes transferred to an airline partner.
- Net result: $3,880 in value, or 4.85 cents/point
This is where points dominate. A 2% cash back card would have only earned $160 on the spending required to get those points.
Common Case (Cash Back)
This is the most straightforward math. If you have credit cards for good credit, you can easily get a 2% cash back card. A family spending $3,000 per month on the card will earn $720 a year. Simple, predictable, and useful for any expense.
Edge Case (When It Fails)
Someone gets a premium travel card with a $550 annual fee, but their travel plans get canceled. They don’t use the travel credits or lounge access. They’ve now paid $550 for a card that’s giving them minimal rewards on their daily spending. Don’t pay for perks you won’t realistically use in the next 12 months.
Gotchas You Shouldn’t Ignore
- Annual Fees That Hit in Year Two: Many cards waive the annual fee for the first year. Set a calendar reminder 11 months after you’re approved to re-evaluate if the card is worth paying for.
- The 5/24 Rule: Some issuers, notably Chase, will automatically deny you for most of their cards if you’ve opened five or more personal credit cards in the past 24 months. This applies to cards from any bank, not just Chase. You need to plan your applications strategically.
- Carrying a Balance: This is the cardinal sin of rewards cards. The interest, often 20%+, will wipe out any rewards you earn. If I can’t pay the statement in full and on time, I don’t use the card. Period. It’s a non-negotiable rule.
How We Picked
The recommendations in this guide are based on my personal system for managing a portfolio of over 15 credit cards. This personal data is combined with ongoing research from trusted industry sources.
What This Means For You
For most beginners, the best first step is a no-annual-fee cash back card. Master it. Pay it off every month. Once you’re comfortable, the Chase Sapphire Preferred® is the ideal next step into the world of travel rewards. The real answer to “what is the best credit card” is the one that fits your life right now. To figure that out, your next step is to analyze your spending.
FAQ
What is the easiest rewards card to get approved for?
Generally, cash back cards with no annual fee are the easiest to get, though most still require a good credit score. Some banks offer pre-approval tools on their websites, which let you check your odds without a hard credit inquiry.
How many credit cards is too many?
It’s too many when you can no longer manage them all responsibly, meaning you miss payments or can’t track the benefits. I know people with 20+ cards who are organized, and people with two who are overwhelmed.
Should my first rewards card be for points or cash back?
For 9 out of 10 beginners, the answer is cash back. It builds good habits, is impossible to redeem for a “bad” value, and provides a clear baseline. Starting with cash back teaches you to think about the return on your spending, which is the foundational skill for all rewards.
